Managing an Employee Grievance: Best Practices

Handling an employee grievance properly isn’t just an HR best practice. It’s a fundamental part of fostering a healthy, respectful, and legally compliant workplace. How employee concerns are handled and resolved can significantly impact morale, trust, and the overall workplace culture.

What is an employee grievance?

A grievance is a formal complaint raised by an employee about a workplace issue that is affecting them. This might include concerns about:

• Bullying or harassment
• Conflict with colleagues or managers
• Health and safety concerns
• Discrimination or unfair treatment
• Breach of policy or contract
• Working conditions

While some concerns may be raised informally at first, a formal grievance process is available when informal discussions haven’t resolved the issue or when the matter is too serious to be addressed informally.

Where possible and appropriate, dealing with issues informally can be quicker, less stressful, and more effective for everyone involved. Informal conversations—such as a quiet word with a manager or a facilitated discussion between colleagues—can often defuse tensions and lead to positive outcomes without the need for a formal process.

Benefits of informal resolution include:

• Quicker resolution of concerns
• Less strain on working relationships
• Reduced need for formal investigations
• Encouragement of open communication
• Preservation of a more collaborative workplace culture

It’s important to remember that not all issues are suitable for informal handling. This is especially the case for those involving serious allegations such as harassment or discrimination. However, in many cases, encouraging early, honest conversations can prevent small problems from becoming big ones.

Getting grievances rights

Grievances are not just procedural hurdles; they’re opportunities to address problems before they escalate. Getting the process right is critical for several reasons:

• Legal Compliance: Mishandling grievances can lead to tribunal claims, especially where discrimination, harassment, or whistleblowing is involved.
• Employee Trust: A fair and transparent grievance process shows employees they are heard and respected, boosting morale and retention.
• Reputation Management: Poor handling of grievances can damage your organisation’s reputation internally and externally.
• Conflict Resolution: Addressing grievances early and fairly can prevent long-term conflicts and improve working relationships.
• Cultural Impact: Consistent fair handling of grievances supports an inclusive, positive, and respectful workplace culture.

Getting grievances wrong

Conversely, getting it wrong can result in:

• Loss of employee trust and engagement
• Higher staff turnover
• Damage to employer brand
• Potential legal action and financial costs
• A toxic workplace environment

Best practice for grievances

A good employee grievance process is clear, fair, timely, and well-documented. Here are some best practice tips:

1. Encourage Early Resolution: Support informal resolution where appropriate and equip managers to handle these conversations with confidence.
2. Follow a Clear Policy: Ensure all staff have access to your grievance procedure and understand how to raise concerns.
3. Act Promptly: Don’t delay responding. Acknowledge receipt quickly and set realistic timescales for next steps.
4. Remain Neutral and Objective: Investigate fairly without bias. Ensure that investigators and decision-makers are impartial.
5. Keep Communication Open: Keep the employee informed at each stage and offer opportunities to discuss concerns face-to-face.
6. Maintain Confidentiality: Handle matters sensitively and discreetly to protect all parties involved.
7. Document Everything: Keep accurate records of all discussions, findings, and decisions made.
8. Learn from Outcomes: Use grievance trends to identify wider organisational issues and improve practices or training where needed.

Grievances can feel challenging, but when handled correctly, they’re a valuable part of a healthy organisation. They offer insights into workplace issues that may otherwise go unnoticed and provide a mechanism for constructive change. By encouraging early conversations and ensuring a fair, transparent process when formal concerns are raised, you demonstrate integrity, fairness, and a genuine commitment to your people.

At HPC, we provide expert guidance in handling employee grievances fairly and efficiently. Our expert team of HR Consultants can help you to establish a clear process, conduct impartial investigations, and mediate disputes to foster a positive workplace culture.

To find out more information or to discuss handling an employee grievance, please get in contact with our team of experts.

T: 0330 107 1037

E: contact@hpc.uk.com

LinkedIn: High Performance Consultancy